Cardboard Christmases: Judging Wear and Missing Counters on a Ten-Pound 1930s Game
Photo: Australian National Maritime Museum on The Commons, No restrictions, via Wikimedia Commons
Somewhere in every saleroom there is a boxed game with a torn lid, held shut by a rubber band that has gone sticky, sitting on top of a stack of jigsaws that nobody has looked at since the summer. The estimate is ten pounds, or it is bundled into a lot with a tea tray, and most bidders walk straight past.
That is a mistake, and not only because a 1930s board game is a small, cheap, beautifully printed slice of social history. It is because the cardboard is honest. Nothing in the lot will tell you more about how it has been treated than a game that was played, folded away and played again for ninety years.
Start with the box corners
Pick the box up and look at the four corners with the lid on. A 1930s game box is usually laminated printed paper over strawboard, and the corners fail first. Neat, original corner folds that have merely softened are fine and expected. Corners that have been re-glued brown, or reinforced with a strip of parcel tape, tell you that someone loved it enough to save it. Old tape is not a disaster — it has probably done its work and gone brittle — but fresh, shiny tape, applied in the last five years, suggests a seller tidying up for sale rather than a family keeping something going.
The lid is the whole point of a period game. Chromolithographed box tops from the 1930s are poster art: bold flat colour, hand-drawn figures, a title in a jaunty script. Compare the print quality on the lid with the print inside. If the lid looks cruder, denser and slightly out of register compared with the board, it may be a later replacement from a different edition. Look at the lid edge for a second line of stitching or staples from a re-fit.
Check the base for damp. Strawboard that has been wet swells, smells sweet and musty, and delaminates in layers like pastry. A soft, puffy base with a tide mark is a case that has lived in a garage since the 1970s — and mould in the paper will not leave politely.
Read the wear on the cards — it is a diary
Lay the cards out on the preview table and pay attention to the difference between use and damage. Used cards have softened corners, a slight greying along the edges from thumbs, and a faint surface polish on the faces. Damaged cards are bent, torn, or have a hard crease. On a snap or happy-families deck, one or two noticeably grubbier cards are almost always the ones everyone reached for.
Look closely at how the cards were made. Thick card with a linen-textured surface and hand-coloured-looking lithography points earlier; thinner card with flat, even colour and a cut edge points later. If the deck is counted — and you should count it — a full set is unusual and good. Missing one card out of forty-eight barely matters in play, but note it, because it affects what you should pay.
Pencil marks are the best thing in the box
This is the part most buyers rub away, and it is the part worth keeping. Scorecards, tallies and the inside of the lid frequently carry pencil names, sums and dates, written by the people who played it. A scorecard with 'Christmas 1937' on it, or a row of four names in careful copperplate and one in childish capitals, converts a ten-pound object into a family document.
Do not rub anything out. Do not clean the pencil off the board. Photograph it, describe it in your notes, and if you ever sell, mention it in the listing — that is the sort of detail that turns a plain game into something a collector wants.
Counters, dice and missing-piece arithmetic
Now for the maths. Games from this period usually used turned wooden counters, small pressed-card discs, or counters punched from a printed sheet inside the box. If you can find a surviving punch sheet with a few counters still in place, you can identify the exact original shapes and colours, which tells you instantly what has gone missing.
A few absent counters are normal and should not put you off. What matters is whether the game is playable. Some rules of thumb:
- Players' pieces: you need one per player for the board to work at all. If four are needed and only two survive, budget for substitutes.
- Dice: check for a full set and look at the material. Bone dice are common; if a die looks like ivory, be aware that the UK's Ivory Act 2018 restricts dealing in ivory items except under narrow exemptions, so research before buying to resell.
- Spinners and teetotums: the pointer is often bent or missing, which is an easy repair but worth knowing about.
- Money and cardboard banknotes: usually the first thing to vanish, and the last thing to worry about, unless you want to play it.
Follow the paper trail
The instruction sheet is the most fragile item in the box and the most informative. Even a torn fragment can carry the maker's name, an edition number, a date code or a royal warrant. The 1930s UK market was dominated by a handful of names — Chad Valley, Waddingtons, Gibson, Spear's and Glevum among them — and the wording on a rules sheet will usually place a game within a decade without much effort. Sometimes there is also a shop sticker on the box, a printed price in shillings, or a label from a long-gone toy department.
Read the rules if they are there. It takes five minutes and it will tell you whether the game is complete enough to actually play on Boxing Day — which, for my money, is the real test of a ten-pound box.
The ten-pound verdict
Buy it if the lid art is intact, the board is flat and dry, the counters work for the number of players you would realistically have round, and there is a pencil date or a name anywhere in the box. Leave it if the base has gone soft, the board has a water stain through the middle, or the whole thing smells like a cellar.
Then take it home, air it for a week, wipe the board with a dry cloth and nothing else, and put the rules in an acid-free sleeve. Do not iron it, do not tape it, and do not throw the scorecard away. Ninety years of Christmas is already packed in there. Your job is just to keep the lid on.